Criteria for Comic Book

Criteria for Comic Book

India or China 2013

1. Are all of the elements (bullets) in the choice included in the comic book?

* 10: All the elements are included and writer does a thorough job.

* 9: Most of the elements are included, but a very minor omission occurred which does not confuse the reader.

* 8: Student puts forth effort to include most of the elements.

* 7: Student includes elements on a basic level but does not go beyond what is required to make the comic book entertaining or encourage the reader to read further.

* 6: Some elements might be included but they are not clear to the reader.

* 5: Some elements are missing.

* 4: More than half of the elements are missing or are not clear to the reader.

2. Does the comic book include correct spelling, punctuation?

* 10: There are no errors or errors that distract the reader.

* 9: One minor error.

* 8: There are only 2-3 errors.

* 7: There are 4 errors.

* 6: There are 5 errors.

* 5: There are 6 errors.

* 4: There are more than six errors

* 3: It does not look like the writer proofread or made an attempt to correct errors before presenting the final draft.

3. Are the historical ideas in the comic book clear? Does the reader understand important ideas when he/she reads it?

* 10: The writer includes ALL of the historical ideas.

* 9: The writer includes ALL of the historical ideas. One idea might be present but might not be developed.

* 8: The writer includes most of the historical ideas. One is missing.

* 7: The historical ideas are present on a basic level with some development.

* 6: One historical idea appears to be missing.

* 5: Two or more historical ideas are missing.

* 4: It does not look like the writer took time to develop important historical ideas.

4. Is